“What about France? His passport indicates he lived there before coming to the United States.”
“I didn’t go there.”
“Then, who on your team did?”
“No one. We didn’t believe it was necessary.”
“Why wasn’t it necessary?”
“We had asked Interpol for a background check on Johan Rilz and it came back clean.”
“What is Interpol?”
“It stands for International Criminal Police Organization. It’s an organization that links the police in more than a hundred countries and facilitates cross-border cooperation. It has several offices throughout Europe and enjoys total access and cooperation from its host countries.”
“That’s nice but it means you didn’t go directly to the police in Berlin, where Rilz was from?”
“No, we did not.”
“Did you directly check with police in Paris, where Rilz lived five years ago?”
“No, we relied on our Interpol contacts for background on Mr. Rilz.”
“The Interpol background pretty much was a check of a criminal arrest record, correct?”
“That was included, yes.”
“What else was included?”
“I’m not sure what else. I don’t work for Interpol.”
“If Mr. Rilz had worked for the police in Paris as a confidential informant on a drug case, would Interpol have given you this information?”
Kinder’s eyes widened for a split second before he answered. It was clear he wasn’t expecting the question, but I couldn’t get a read on whether he knew where I was heading or if it was all new to him.
“I don’t know whether they would have given us that information or not.”
“Law enforcement agencies usually don’t give out the names of their confidential informants willy-nilly, do they?”
“No, they don’t.”
“Why is that?”
“Because it might put the informants in danger.”
“So being an informant in a criminal case can be dangerous?”
“On occasion, yes.”
“Detective, have you ever investigated the murder of a confidential informant?”
Golantz stood up before Kinder could answer and asked the judge for a sidebar conference. The judge signaled us up. I grabbed the file off the lectern and followed Golantz up. The court reporter moved next to the bench with her steno machine. The judge rolled his chair over and we huddled.
“Mr. Golantz?” the judge prompted.
“Judge, I would like to know where this is going, because I’m feeling like I’m being sandbagged here. There has been nothing in any of the defense’s discovery that even hints at what Mr. Haller is asking the witness about.”
The judge swiveled in his chair and looked at me.
“Mr. Haller?”
“Judge, if anybody is being sandbagged, it’s my client. This was a sloppy investigation that-”
“Save it for the jury, Mr. Haller. Whaddaya got?”
I opened the file and put a computer printout down in front of the judge, which positioned it upside down to Golantz.
“What I’ve got is a story that ran in
“Mr. Haller, again, save your argument for the jury. This printout is in French. Do you have the translation?”
“Sorry, Your Honor.”
I took the second of three sheets out of the file and put it down on top of the first, again in the direction of the judge. Golantz was twisting his head awkwardly as he tried to read it.
“How do we know this is the same Johan Rilz?” Golantz said. “It’s a common name over there.”
“Maybe in Germany, but not in France.”
“So how do we know it’s him?” the judge asked this time. “This is a translated newspaper article. This isn’t any kind of official document.”
I pulled the last sheet from the file and put it down.
“This is a photocopy of a page from Rilz’s passport. I got it from the state’s own discovery. It shows that Rilz left France for the United States in March, two thousand three. One month after this story was published. Plus, you’ve got the age. The article has his age right and it says he was making drug buys for the cops out of his business as an interior decorator. It obviously is him, Your Honor. He betrayed a lot of people over there and put them in jail, then he comes here and starts over.”
Golantz started shaking his head in a desperate sort of way.
“It’s still no good,” he said. “This is a violation of the rules of discovery and is inadmissible. You can’t sit on this and then sucker punch the state with it.”
The judge swiveled his view to me and this time gave me the squint as well.
“Your Honor, if anybody sat on anything, it was the state. This is stuff the prosecution should’ve come up with and given to me. In fact, I think the witness did know about this and
“That is a serious accusation, Mr. Haller,” the judge intoned. “Do you have evidence of that?”
